Criticisms & Commentary

UN racism rapporteur says Singapore's free speech restrictions are outdated

At the end of his eight-day visit to Singapore, United Nations official Githu Muigai criticised the Republic's limits on free speech. "It is absolutely necessary in a free society that restrictions on public debate or discourse and the protection of racial harmony are not implemented at the detriment of fundamental human rights, such as the freedom of expression and the freedom of assembly," said the UN's Special Rapporteur on Contemporary Forms of Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance. Full Story

Parliament debates election coverage of mainstream and alternative media

Nominated MP Viswa Sadasivan, who used to cover elections for Singapore's national broadcaster in his first career as a current affairs television producer, said in Parliament that the "cooling off" period should apply to his old employers and other mainstream media, and not just to the political parties. Their news coverage was inherently "subjective in nature", he said. Law Minister K Shanmugam defended the credibility of Singapore's national media before the House passed the Bill that would ban campaigning – but not news reports – on the eve of Polling Day. Full Story

Activists tell UN that racial harmony here is a media myth

Singaporeans For Democracy has told the visiting UN Special Rapporteur on Racism that the situation here is less harmonious than the government makes it out to be. The group, spearheaded by activist James Gomez, said that the lack of freedom of expression was denying citizens the chance to discuss problems openly. Full Story

Official Views

Public expression of religious views must be sensitive to others

WONG KAN SENG

Deputy Prime Minister Wong Kan Seng says it's a security concern when "religiosity manifests itself in a highly public and assertive manner in a multireligious setting like Singapore". An extract from his recent speech. Full Story

Independent Judiciary requires respect and support of public

CHAN SEK KEONG, CHIEF JUSTICE OF SINGAPORE

In a democratic society, the respect and support of the public is, in fact, one of the best safeguards for the independence of the Judiciary as an institution. Conversely, a lack of respect and support from the public for the Judiciary and its functions can be detrimental to its independence. However, mechanisms such as the doctrine of contempt should not be used to stifle fair and reasonable criticism of the work of the Judiciary and also judicial decisions. Full Story

Chief Justice on Defamation: Court must go by values expressed in law

Chief Justice Chan Sek Keong has said that critics may be missing the point when they accuse Singapore's courts of lack of independence in defamation cases involving the government. He said that the balance between defamation and free speech was "much misunderstood". In Singapore, "the drafters of the Constitution decided, in their wisdom, to place a higher social value on reputation than on free speech, where they conflict." Critics were missing the point by criticising the Courts "for recognising the political, social and cultural values of Singapore society as expressed in its laws". Full Story